Chinese President Xi Jinping referred to the ancient Greek historian Thucydides during his trilateral meeting with US President Donald Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin in Shenzhen, on the sidelines of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit. The term he used describes one of the greatest risks in relations between powerful states: the possibility that a rising power will come into conflict with an established, dominant one.
Xi’s remarks at the summit
According to Chinese state broadcaster CCTV and the Associated Press, Xi stressed that China, the United States and Russia should respect one another’s “red lines”, treat each other as partners and friends, and seek to overcome the “Thucydides Trap”.
What the Thucydides Trap means
The Thucydides Trap describes a dangerous pattern in international relations.
When one country grows stronger economically, militarily and politically and begins to challenge another’s primacy, the dominant power may come to feel threatened. Fear of losing power, together with suspicion and growing rivalry, can escalate tensions and even lead to war.
In today’s international context, the rising power is China and the established power whose position is being challenged is the United States. The rivalry between the two plays out on many fronts, from the economy and global trade to military strength, technology and artificial intelligence.
The historical basis in the Peloponnesian War
The theory is rooted in the Peloponnesian War, fought from 431 to 404 BC between Athens and Sparta and their allies.
In examining the deeper causes of the conflict, Thucydides argued that the decisive factors were the growing power of Athens and the fear it caused in Sparta.
In his History of the Peloponnesian War, in Book 1, Chapter 23, the historian identifies this shift in the balance of power as the underlying cause of the war. Sparta feared that Athens was becoming strong enough to threaten its dominance and interests.
Who coined the term
Although the theory draws on Thucydides’ analysis, the ancient historian never used the phrase “Thucydides Trap”himself.
The term was coined in modern times by American political scientist Graham Allison, a professor at Harvard University. Allison set out the theory in his 2017 book Destined for War: Can America and China Escape Thucydides’s Trap?
Allison’s historical cases
As part of his research, Allison examined 16 historical cases in which a rising power threatened to displace a dominant one.
- In 12 cases, the result was war
- In four cases, conflict was avoided
The analysis is not a prediction that the United States and China will inevitably go to war. It highlights the risks that rivalry creates and the importance of diplomacy in preventing conflict.
The context of Xi’s message
Xi’s reference came as the rivalry between Washington and Beijing is intensifying, and as Russia remains in confrontation with the West over the war in Ukraine.
By raising the Thucydides Trap, Xi called on the United States, China and Russia to avoid a course of uncontrolled confrontation that could threaten international stability.
With information from CCTV and the Associated Press


