EU Tobacco Rules Review Delayed After Regulatory Setback

Header Image

The European Commission's planned overhaul of tobacco and nicotine rules has been delayed after a negative assessment of its impact study.

The European Commission's review of EU legislation governing tobacco and nicotine products has encountered a setback after the accompanying impact assessment received a negative opinion from the Regulatory Scrutiny Board (RSB).

According to Table.Briefings, the development has cast uncertainty over the timetable for presenting the new measures.

The review concerns both the Tobacco Products Directive (TPD) and the Tobacco Advertising Directive (TAD), two key pieces of EU legislation regulating the production, sale and promotion of tobacco products.

The proposed reforms are also expected to cover newer nicotine products, including electronic cigarettes. Among the issues under consideration are potential restrictions on flavourings used in e-cigarette liquids, as part of wider public health efforts.

Why the proposal was blocked

The Regulatory Scrutiny Board examines whether legislative initiatives are supported by sufficient evidence regarding their economic and social consequences, impacts on businesses and competitiveness, and whether alternative policy options have been properly assessed.

The negative opinion means the supporting documentation requires further work before the legislative process can move forward.

Should a second negative opinion be issued, special procedures would require the proposal to be referred to the College of Commissioners, which would then decide whether the initiative should proceed despite the concerns raised.

According to Table.Briefings, European Commissioner for Health Olivér Várhelyi had hoped to present the revised proposal during the final meeting of the College of Commissioners for 2026, scheduled for December 15.

However, objections from the Commission's Secretariat-General, combined with the negative assessment, have made that timetable uncertain.

A Commission spokesperson told Table.Briefings that work on the proposal is continuing and that officials aim to present it as soon as possible, although no new timetable has been announced.

The Cyprus dimension

In Cyprus, the tobacco market is already facing significant challenges linked to illicit trade and the particular circumstances created by the Green Line.

According to KPMG's annual study, the share of illicit cigarettes in Cyprus rose to 16.3% of total consumption in 2025, up from 14.3% in 2024.

Consumption of illicit cigarettes is estimated at around 160 million cigarettes, while lost tax revenue is estimated at approximately €27 million.

These figures highlight the potential risks associated with additional restrictions if they are not accompanied by a thorough assessment of their impact on the legal market.

In particular, changes affecting the availability or characteristics of specific products may need to be considered in light of the possibility that consumers could shift towards unregulated distribution channels.

Tax discussions also unresolved

The delay to the legislative review comes as negotiations remain ongoing over the taxation of tobacco products within the EU.

Malta continues to oppose the proposed reform of European tobacco taxation, despite support from 26 of the EU's 27 member states.

Source: Table.Briefings