Oversight Committee for Officials and Judges: Monitoring Mechanism for Conflicts of Interest and Private Sector Employment

Header Image

A Committee for the Investigation of Incompatibilities and Post-Public Employment is to be established to examine incompatibilities involving public officials and to approve or reject applications by former officials, judges and senior public servants seeking employment in the private sector. Under a bill submitted to parliament by Justice Minister Costas Fytiris, the two existing committees will be abolished in a bid to address shortcomings and weaknesses identified in their operation. At the same time, the list of officials subject to scrutiny will be expanded.

 

A new committee will assume responsibility for overseeing the professional activities of officials, whether elected or appointed, examining potential incompatibilities and conflicts of interest. The three-member committee will review officials' professional activities before they assume office and determine whether they may continue them. It will also be empowered to approve or reject applications by former officials, judges and senior employees of the public and wider public sector seeking employment in the private sector during the first two years following their departure or retirement.

The measure establishes a new oversight mechanism aimed at preventing conflicts of interest both while a public office is held and after an official leaves it. The establishment of the committee, which is also a recommendation of the Council of Europe's anti-corruption body GRECO, is provided for in a Justice Ministry bill submitted to parliament for approval the day before yesterday. Under the new framework, the two existing committees that currently examine these matters separately will be abolished, while efforts will be made to address gaps and weaknesses identified in their operation. At the same time, the list of officials subject to review will be broadened.

According to the Justice Ministry, the main objective of the bill is to create a comprehensive mechanism for monitoring incompatibilities involving public officials, preventing conflicts between their public duties and private interests, and safeguarding transparency and integrity in public administration. Within the same framework, oversight of employment in the private sector after leaving public office or a public-sector position is intended to protect the public interest.

Three-member committee

The new Committee for the Investigation of Incompatibilities and Post-Public Employment will be appointed by the Council of Ministers for a five-year term, renewable once. Its chairperson will be a person possessing the qualifications required for appointment as a judge of the Supreme Constitutional Court or the Supreme Court. The other two members will be the Accountant General of the Republic, or a senior official of the Treasury serving at salary scale A15, and a public prosecutor or senior government lawyer nominated by the Attorney-General.

Decisions within 30 days

The bill sets specific timeframes for examining applications concerning both incompatibilities and employment in the private sector.

Specifically, the committee must examine applications and issue decisions within 30 days of completing its review or receiving the applicant's written representations. In cases requiring more detailed investigation, the deadline may be extended by a further 30 days. Significant delays are currently observed in decisions issued by the two existing committees, which will be abolished once the bill is enacted.

Accountability

The committee will submit an annual report to the Council of Ministers detailing its activities, statistical data on applications, cases and complaints, as well as its observations and recommendations. The report will be tabled in parliament and published in the Official Gazette of the Republic.

Incompatible activities

The bill specifies certain activities and positions that officials will be prohibited from undertaking or holding throughout their term of office. Among other things, officials will be barred from personally entering into contracts for the provision of works or services to the public or wider public sector, or to state-owned and semi-governmental organisations.

They will also be prohibited from participating in, or holding management positions as chairman or member of a board of directors, governor, director-general or deputy director-general, in private-sector companies, cooperatives, joint ventures or businesses that submit tenders for, enter into, or undertake contracts with the public or wider public sector, or with state-owned and semi-governmental organisations.

Incompatible activities will also include serving as an executive director, chairman, board member or director of a public or private company, as well as a public-law legal entity, involved in electronic or print media.

Officials subject to oversight, whether elected or appointed, will be required to submit a declaration to the committee within 15 days of taking office, setting out their professional activities.

Employment in the private sector

Particular emphasis is placed on provisions concerning professional activity after leaving public office or a public-sector position. The bill seeks to regulate the move of former officials, judges and senior public servants into the private sector in order to prevent conflicts of interest and the exploitation of information or decisions linked to their previous public role.

Specifically, officials, judges and senior employees of the public and wider public sector who have retired or otherwise left office will be required to obtain prior approval from the committee if they wish to take up employment with a specific private-sector employer during the first two years following their departure or retirement.

When examining applications, the committee will consider specific criteria to determine whether the proposed employment creates an actual or potential conflict of interest. Among the factors to be examined are:

  • Any dealings the applicant may have had with the prospective employer in the course of their duties during the previous two years.
  • Whether the applicant had access to sensitive commercial or other information concerning competitors of the prospective employer.
  • Whether the applicant participated in decision-making or provided advice benefiting the prospective employer in a manner that could be perceived as a reward for future employment.
  • Whether the applicant participated in formulating policies that had not yet been announced and knowledge of which could benefit the prospective employer.
  • In the case of judges, whether they had access, in the course of their duties, to confidential or other information that could lead to a conflict of interest or to a situation that could objectively be perceived as such upon their employment.

Based on these criteria, the committee may approve private-sector employment with or without conditions, or reject the relevant application.

Prison sentences of up to three years

The bill also provides for criminal penalties for those who fail to comply with their obligations towards the committee. These include:

  • A person who fails to submit an application to the committee, whether concerning incompatibility or private-sector employment, or who refuses or fails to appear before it, commits an offence and, upon conviction, is liable to up to one year in prison, a fine of up to €10,000, or both.
  • A person who submits false or inaccurate information to the committee commits an offence and, upon conviction, is liable to up to three years in prison, a fine of up to €30,000, or both.