A total of €64 million in liabilities arising from penalties for undeclared work could be erased if parliament approves legislation submitted by the government.
With retrospective effect from June 2017, the Ministry of Labour is proposing to reduce outstanding undeclared-work penalties from €73 million to €9 million. The stated aim is to curb the ballooning surcharges generated by a daily penalty of €50.
Who are the beneficiaries?
The Christodoulides administration argues that the debts have become excessive and difficult to collect.
Yet serious questions remain. Which employers, businesses and self-employed individuals stand to benefit from this substantial reduction? Will their identities be made public so that society knows who is being relieved of liabilities worth tens of millions of euros?
This is not merely a transparency issue. It is also a question of accountability.
The proposed measure would effectively forgo €64 million in public revenue. It also raises questions of equal treatment between businesses and entrepreneurs who comply with labour legislation, including paying penalties imposed on them, and those who violate the law and leave the fines unpaid.
Equally important is the message sent when the state chooses to retrospectively reduce the financial consequences of unlawful conduct.
MPs should not be expected to approve a measure of this scale without knowing who will benefit and to what extent. Nor should society be expected to accept the cancellation of tens of millions of euros without knowing who the recipients are.
Lawbreakers and personal data
Members of the House Labour Committee requested from the ministry a list of the employers and self-employed individuals who would benefit from the €64 million reduction.
However, according to information obtained by this column, the response is expected to be the now familiar one: personal data protection.
"We would be violating their personal data."
Whose personal data exactly?
Those who broke the law?
Those who employed undeclared workers?
Apparently so.
The situation once again illustrates a point repeatedly made in this column: that personal data legislation has increasingly become a refuge for those seeking to avoid scrutiny and accountability.
How did the debt reach €73 million?
Current legislation provides for an administrative fine of €1,000 for every undeclared employee discovered working for an employer, while self-employed individuals face a fine of €200.
The fine must be paid within 30 days, with a 30 per cent discount available for prompt payment.
If payment is delayed, however, an additional €50 per day is added.
As a result, initial penalties amounting to roughly €2.5 million, imposed on around 1,000 employers, businesses and self-employed individuals, eventually grew to €73 million.
The court cases
At the same time, the Social Insurance Services have filed civil actions against individuals and companies seeking to recover both the original penalties and the accumulated daily surcharges.
None of those cases has yet reached a final judgment.
If parliament approves the proposed legislation and €64 million is written off, the pending court claims will inevitably be affected as the sums being pursued will be reduced accordingly.
Parliament is therefore not merely being asked to correct a provision that proved problematic in practice.
It is being asked to approve the cancellation of €64 million in penalties imposed for breaches of labour legislation, with direct consequences for the finances of the Social Insurance Fund.
Before voting, lawmakers ought to know exactly who will benefit from this extraordinarily generous arrangement.
Transparency cannot be applied selectively, nor can personal data protection be used as an excuse to avoid accountability for those who broke the law.



